Indy Ekes Out 3-2 Win, Penguins Night Tonight at Wesbanco Arena

-

WHEELING, WV- Friday night’s game between the Wheeling Nailers and Indy Fuel at WesBanco Arena took two hours and 54 minutes to play, as the two sides needed every second of regulation, plus overtime and a shootout to determine a winner.

Indy’s Jadon Joseph avenged an unsuccessful penalty shot in overtime by delivering the deciding goal in the second round of the shootout. Mitchell Weeks followed that up by denying the last two shooters for Wheeling, as the Fuel prevailed, 3-2.

The Nailers have a big night of fun ahead of them on Saturday at 7:10 p.m., when they play host to the Cincinnati Cyclones. The promotion is the annual Pittsburgh Penguins Night and two-time Stanley Cup Champion and current broadcast analyst Phil Bourque will be the celebrity guest. Bourque will sign autographs before the game and during the first intermission, before heading up to the broadcast booth to join DJ Abisalih and Brock Woods for the second period.

Scoring chances were few and far between in the first period Friday night as the shots on goal were 7-4 in Indy’s favor. The Fuel tallied the lone goal in the stanza, which came with 5:05 remaining on a transition rush. Tyler Paquette carried the puck into the offensive zone, then delivered the pass to his right for defenseman Nick Grima.

Grima proceeded to set up Jadon Joseph, who drove in a one-timer from the left circle.

The Nailers didn’t waste much time in evening the score in the middle frame, as the equalizer came at the one-minute mark. Brayden Edwards carried the puck toward the slot, looking to create a scoring chance. A poke check by Indy made the puck slide off of Edwards’ blade to Matty De St. Phalle, who immediately shoveled a shot up and into the top-left corner of the cage.

Wheeling did a better job of controlling the play in period two with a 13-9 shots advantage in the 1-1 deadlock.

The two teams exchanged goals in quick succession during the third period. At the 3:36 mark, Grima’s shot from the top of the right circle produced a rebound, which was tucked inside of the right post by Jesse Tucker to put Indy ahead, 2-1. However, Wheeling responded 20 seconds later on the power play. Zach Urdahl’s shot from the left circle was denied, but Logan Pietila cleaned up the loose change on the right side of the crease to knot the tilt, 2-2. T

he Nailers outshot the Fuel, 15-11 in the third period, but neither team could break the tie, sending the match to overtime.

Somehow, the extra session didn’t decide a winner either, despite a 4-2 shots advantage for Indy. The biggest chance of overtime came at the 5:29 mark, when Joseph was awarded a penalty shot. However, Taylor Gauthier made a blocker side, and the teams kept playing.

Eventually, a shootout was needed to settle the score. Both shooters succeeded in round one – Eric Martin for the Fuel and Zach Urdahl for Wheeling. Joseph gave Indy the advantage in the second round, when he slammed a shot through Gauthier’s legs. The Nailers were unable to answer that, as Mitchell Weeks thwarted Logan Pietila and Brent Johnson for a 3-2 Fuel victory.

Mitchell Weeks backstopped the win for Indy, as he made 32 saves on 34 shots during the game, then went two-of-three in the shootout. Taylor Gauthier turned away 29 of the 31 shots he faced during the game for Wheeling, then made one stop on three shootout attempts.

Tonight’s giveaway item is a beanie hat, the Nailers will be wearing specialty jerseys designed after Pittsburgh’s from the 2008 NHL Winter Classic, and there will be a full team autograph session following the game. Individual tickets, group tickets, and more are available now by calling (304) 234-GOAL. The Wheeling Nailers, considered one of the top things to do in Wheeling, West Virginia, provide affordable family entertainment for fans throughout the Ohio Valley.

Steve Novotney
Steve Novotney
Steve Novotney has been a professional journalist for 33 years, working in print for weekly, daily, and bi-weekly publications, writing for a number of regional and national magazines, host baseball-related talks shows on Pittsburgh’s ESPN, and as a daily, all-topics talk show host in the Wheeling and Steubenville markets since 2004. Novotney is the co-owner, editor, and co-publisher of LEDE News, and is the host of “Novotney Now,” a daily program that airs Monday-Friday from 3-6 p.m. on River Talk 100.1 & 100.9 FM.

LATEST POSTS

Wheeling Nailers News & Notes – March 4, 2026

The Nailers will return to Wesbanco Arena on March 13th for a 'Frosty Friday'.

Fort Wayne Steals Overtime Win From Nailers, 3-2

Wheeling's next home game is the annual sold-out Education Day Game on Wednesday, March 11th at 10:45 a.m. against the Reading Royals.

Komets Spoil Wheeling’s Comeback, 6-4

The Nailers will play this afternoon at 4:10 p.m. in downtown Wheeling.

Wheeling Whips Wings, 7-2

Sunday's game is the annual Faith & Family Day, which will feature a post-game celebration of faith with player testimonials, live music, and more.